Cooler or keg for a tun

Just starting out? Find answers to commonly asked homebrewing questions here!
Post Reply
Oilguy
Posts: 11
Joined: |25 Oct 2014|, 11:12
Favourite Beer: Jolson Canadian

Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Oilguy »

I was wandering what is better to use for a mash tun, I have 3. 58 litre kegs as well I have hnumerous rectangular coolers, is any better or worse, I have yet to brew , just getting all my equipment together. Thanks for your input

Doc_Drive
Posts: 1039
Joined: |12 Feb 2013|, 14:55
Favourite Beer: German wheat
Location: Calgary

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Doc_Drive »

I wouldn't go back to coolers (I started with one).

Put in a false bottom in your keg and you're good to go! I'll post a picture of my (completely chaotic) system when I brew next (this Sunday).

Forget the cooler, use the keg. That's my opinion...

Winger
Posts: 384
Joined: |10 Nov 2012|, 14:55
Favourite Beer: BEER
Location: Creston, BC

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Winger »

The cooler method is the simplest and cheapest and works fine. I started with a rectangular cooler, built a manifold and drain, and used it for a year. It still sits in my shop and I use for other purposes nowadays. I've moved up to a 58 L keg, still with a manifold, as a tun. The expense to build the keg tun was 10 times the simple cooler with fittings and welding, and I did the welding myself. Not everyone has the equipment or skill to weld fittings into a very thin stainless steel keg. If you are just beginning and unsure if this hobby is something that will be a long time passion, I say start with a cooler tun. That's just my opinion. :cheers:
Some mistakes are too much fun to only make once.

Doc_Drive
Posts: 1039
Joined: |12 Feb 2013|, 14:55
Favourite Beer: German wheat
Location: Calgary

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Doc_Drive »

converting a keg (especially if you have one already) doesn't have to be very expensive. I have one port that's welded onto it (an acquintance of mine did that in exchange for a beer) and the rest is done with weldless fittings... It is more expensive to convert a keg but in my opinion not extremely more...

Oilguy
Posts: 11
Joined: |25 Oct 2014|, 11:12
Favourite Beer: Jolson Canadian

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Oilguy »

Thanks for the feed back , I think I will go the keg route , I have some SS solder paste on order so I will give it a go at soldering,

kombat
Member
Posts: 385
Joined: |14 Sep 2012|, 13:49
Favourite Beer: Broadhead Wildcard

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by kombat »

I have 2 coolers (48 quart and 70 quart), one is for 5 gallon batches, the other is for 10 gallon batches and high-gravity 5 gallon batches. I like them because if I preheat them with some hot water while heating strike water, they hold temperature wonderfully during even longer mashes (2 hours). No complaints, no reason to modify my process.

User avatar
Warthaug
Posts: 852
Joined: |09 Apr 2011|, 19:50
Favourite Beer: The wet kind
Location: SW Ontario
Contact:

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Warthaug »

I've been brewing for nearly 17 years, with both types of funds, and I prefer cooler systems. They hold the heat, which means recirculation is unnessusary - and if you incorporate a recirculation system it will (in my experience) be mute stable.
Visit my blog at suigenerisbrewing.com. Homebrewing, yeast wrangling, wild yeast and more!

Doc_Drive
Posts: 1039
Joined: |12 Feb 2013|, 14:55
Favourite Beer: German wheat
Location: Calgary

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Doc_Drive »

Point taken Brian...

I guess I got lucky finding a rubberized keg...

Goulaigan
Posts: 456
Joined: |14 Jan 2014|, 23:05
Favourite Beer: Mine
Location: Goulais River, ON

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by Goulaigan »

There is also an even simpler option, you could BIAB. You already have the stuff to go 3 vessel, but when it comes to homebrewing in my opinion the same great beer can be made with BIAB. All in one vessel, less cleaning, less time... Since you haven't brewed, might also be a good way to get your process down, even if you plan to do the 3 vessel route down the road.
Happy brewing whatever road you take.... My 2 cents

:cheers:

User avatar
JimmehBrew
Posts: 803
Joined: |13 May 2012|, 11:36
Favourite Beer: Bass Pale Ales
Location: Barrie Ont CA
Contact:

Re: Cooler or keg for a tun

Post by JimmehBrew »

Goulaigan wrote:There is also an even simpler option, you could BIAB. You already have the stuff to go 3 vessel, but when it comes to homebrewing in my opinion the same great beer can be made with BIAB. All in one vessel, less cleaning, less time... Since you haven't brewed, might also be a good way to get your process down, even if you plan to do the 3 vessel route down the road.
Happy brewing whatever road you take.... My 2 cents

:cheers:
I'm with Goul , if i was starting over ( which I am )or doing it again for the first time BIAB is how it would be. Electric kettle, 1 pump, insulation for kettle for mashing or a rims eventually, and a BIAB, just have to finish selling whats left of my old gear :rockon:
Image

Post Reply