First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Homebrewing with extract? Share your thoughts here!
Post Reply
Kremlock
Posts: 12
Joined: 7 years ago
Favourite Beer: Stout
Location: Ottawa, Ontario

First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by Kremlock » 7 years ago

Hi all,

I just wanted to share my experience on my first brew with you all. I made http://tastybrew.com/newrcp/detail/410 yesterday. I actually did start with a 3.5 gal boil as my pot could handle it and figured that i would benefit from more water in contact with the grains steeping and the hops boiling (not sure if that was a mistake or a positive choice)

I hydrated and proofed 1 package of Safale US-05 in a cup of pre-boiled water mixed with 1 tsp of extract. That turned out nice when I pitched at 72F.

My chill took 25 minutes in a tub full of Ice. I discovered that if you move the ice around in the tub the wort chills out faster.

So here is where I got stunned! I had boiled 3 gal of water prior to everything to top off in my fermentor so that I could could get to 5.5 Gal as the recipe suggested.

That is where my surprise happened. I topped off and hit the 4.5 gal mark! what? So this means I lost a total 2 gal during the steep, and the boil. I could not believe it. Well I was 45 min late to a super we where going to so I did not have the time to prepare enough water to top off at this time.

So I pitched at 72F and hoped for the best and the OG was 1.062

This morning I took at look at is, what a beautiful and creamy krausen on top. Oh and you can smell the hops...NICE!

Would anyone suggest adding more water to bring the volume to 5.5 gal or just leave as is?
Lessons learned:

1. Start in the morning and do no commit to plans as this takes some time
2. Boil more water then you need for when you top off
3. Hops smell wonderful
4. THIS IS FUN!

User avatar
Canuck
Moderator
Posts: 2156
Joined: 8 years ago
Favourite Beer: All of them
Location: Quispamsis, New Brunswick
Contact:

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by Canuck » 7 years ago

I would definitely leave it as is at this point. Oh, and your 4 lessons learned are spot on. :D

DWN
Posts: 20
Joined: 8 years ago

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by DWN » 7 years ago

Don't mess with it. It will be fine. Later Don.

Kremlock
Posts: 12
Joined: 7 years ago
Favourite Beer: Stout
Location: Ottawa, Ontario

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by Kremlock » 7 years ago

thanks everyone

User avatar
donaldrstewart
Posts: 19
Joined: 8 years ago
Location: Nova Scotia

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by donaldrstewart » 7 years ago

If you use the recipe calculator on brewersfriend.com, (or other similar sites), save the recipe. Then and if you select to brew your recipe, the calculator will show how much water you will need in total to brew your recipe to your target volume. Basically the calculator (and other similar ones), takes into account water lost due to boil off during the boil period.

birvine
Posts: 1162
Joined: 8 years ago
Location: Cochrane, Ontario
Contact:

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by birvine » 7 years ago

Now you know how much water you boil off in a given amount of time for your setup (each setup is different). Record that and adjust your calculations to suit.

Brent
Northeastern Ontario's own...
Swan Lane Brewery and Winery

User avatar
ihomebrewing
Moderator
Posts: 611
Joined: 8 years ago
Location: Windsor, Ontario
Contact:

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by ihomebrewing » 7 years ago

I would not ever add water to a wort post boil.... It...Just...doesn't...seem...right...

I have had beers overshoot and undershoot the gravity, and that is just the way it goes when you are developing a recipe. I am of the mind that it will turn out great anyhow, and the numbers combined with the tasting notes are the correct way to develop proper brewing technique, with regards to recipe development. Learn all you can from this, and make a decision to either change the procedure next brew... or you may decide that it is perfect the way it is.

There is much more information to be gleaned by sticking it out and not trying to meet some arbitrary number. Look at it this way: If you DID mess with your wort post boil, and it turned out horrible, where do you even start in finding the culprit?

Keep your brewing consistent, is my opinion; and for me, that does not include messing with a properly finished wort, even when the numbers aren't exactly what you were expecting...

Cheers,

Bryan

User avatar
Jack
Posts: 441
Joined: 8 years ago
Location: Grafton, Ontario

Re: First brew, question as to add more water or not.

Post by Jack » 7 years ago

When you put it that way Bryan, it's awfully hard not to agree. I have added water after the boil previously, but your comment has made me rethink things. I have to admit that i commit the sin of not using a hydrometer much anymore since i don't rack to a secondary. I was always paranoid about exposure when taking the sample and i'm not too concerned if i hit a specific number, i figure 3-4 weeks in the primary will do it. Before you all warn me about the risks, i already know. Maybe if/when i have problems from doing that i'll smaren up! :$
I'd rather have a bottle in front of me than a frontal lobotomy.

Post Reply